One Way Mirror Season 1, Episode 15: Jeffray Scullin Jr.

1

Sherri Papini

Sherri has mysteriously vanished, and police turn to her husband for answers; when she appears on the side of a California turnpike with her hair chopped off and several injuries, everyone is relieved she was able to get away from her captors.

43 min

2

Grant Amato

A man and his parents are found murdered in their own home. Grant, the brother and son, is brought in for questioning by police. As Grant's recent troubles are laid on the table, he's confronted with the weight of how it all points to motive.

43 min

3

Daniel Clay

After Chelsea Bruck goes missing from an outdoor Halloween party, friends and family are devastated when her remains are found over 6-months later. An exhaustive search of party goers lead authorities to Daniel Clay, a serial offender with a history of assault. By cozying up to Clay, interrogators slowly unravel the events of the evening, and just how deplorable one man can be.

43 min

4

Michael Olson

Michael believes he's being questioned by the authorities about his involvement in a burglary, but the stakes are much higher than he even realizes. A woman has been found murdered and placed in her storage locker, and Michael is the prime suspect.

43 min

5

Daniel Bartelt

When 19-year-old Jessie Blodgett is found strangled, authorities scramble to find the chief subject. They land on one-time boyfriend Daniel Bartelt. Seemingly someone with everything going for him, his demeanor wavers when evidence is brought up of another incident that he fits the description of, putting Bartelt, and his veneer of perfection, into the hot seat.

43 min

6

Brendt Allen Christensen

When a foreign woman goes missing while in America for a year of research, the hunt for the responsible party is considered top priority. Brendt is suspected of being the last person to have seen her alive, and as such, he may be the investigation's only hope for answers.

43 min

7

David Randall Wright

An execution style shooting outside a local restaurant leaves Raul Cuadros dead. Closed-circuit camera footage lead to known felon David Randall Wright. Wright, a whip-smart career criminal leads interrogators down a winding path as they hope to uncover what really happened between him and Cuadros, leaving police to wonder, whose interrogating who?

43 min

8

Rebecca Fenton

Rebecca calls the police when she finds her husband dead in their own living room. When the police begin to suspect that this widow could be a suspect, they must find a balance between pushing for the truth and potentially accusing an innocent woman struggling with grief.

43 min

9

Chris Adam Waide

When Lea Porter stops communicating with family members, they discover that she's found herself in a jam, and connected with Chris Adam Waide, a smooth-talking student ambassador at a local college. With Lea missing police bring in Waide, who's polished portrayal of himself tarnishes the more he keeps talking.

43 min

10

Angela Stoldt

Angela has already confessed to the murder of her neighbor before she's even made it to the interrogation room. As the police start to question her, it's not a matter of what she's done, but what has pushed her so far as to see this as her only option.

43 min

11

Lee Rodarte Jr.

Security Camera footage gives police a different point of view than the one Lee Rodarte Jr. is presenting after 21-year-old Savannah Gold goes missing. Interrogators must navigate restaurant romance while trying to find out exactly what happened between the young waitress and her manager Rodarte Jr.

43 min

12

Robert Glenn Earley

A woman is reporting missing while visiting her boyfriend, Robert, in New Mexico. As Robert begins to explain the events that led to her disappearance, investigators find holes in his story that start to bring the whole event into question.

43 min

13

James Lally

James Lally readily admits that he has killed his partner Suzanne LaPierre. But it will take more than confession for police to locate her body, leading authorities to a long interrogation with an unsettled character who seems more concerned with his own comfort, that the dignity of his late partner.

43 min

14

Ashley McArthur

An extremely messy divorce leads to a woman hiding a large sum of money with one of her closest friends in the world. However, when the woman goes missing, her friend, Ashley, is believed to be involved in something more than just attempted fraud.

43 min

15

Jeffray Scullin Jr.

After Melinda Pleskovic is discovered dead in her home just days before her daughter's wedding, police turn to her future son-in-law when his story doesn't seem to add up. But he has news of his own, a series of break-ins at the Pleskovic home may reveal the culprit, and it does, it's just far closer to home than anyone would have imagined.

43 min

16

Samantha Wohlford

A violent home invasion leaves Samantha tied up while her husband is kidnapped and then murdered. As Samantha explains to authorities exactly what happened to her, it's looking more and more likely that there could be more to this crime than what it initially seems.

43 min

17

Skylar Nemetz

Soldier Skylar Nemetz faces interrogation over his wife Danielle's death after claiming a lapse in gun safety. Authorities doubt his training could lead to such an accident, questioning his identity and military skills.

43 min

18

Gregg Mathu & Douglass Detrie

A new mother is found murdered soon after she's reported missing. Her partner and his best friend are brought in to be interrogated about her final night. But not every interrogation method works with every suspect, and not every theory proves true.

43 min

19

Donald Hartung

When Donald Hartung learns of his mother and brother's deaths, his reaction is flat, leading authorities to refuse to accept that he wasn't already aware of their murder. While they wait for forensics to come in, interrogators struggle to break through Hartung's stoic facade and come dangerously close to violating his rights by bringing his faith into question.

43 min

20

Stephen Mark McDaniel

Stephen is questioned after he speaks to various news outlets about the search for a woman missing from his building. But when Stephen appears to shut down completely, the challenge moves from looking for a confession to trying to get him to speak at all.

43 min

21

Jeffrey Pelo

Sergeant Jeffrey Pelo is brought in for questioning after he was identified prowling outside a young women's house in the middle of the night. Adamant he's done nothing wrong, interrogators walk a tight rope questioning one of their own, who knows all too well the kind of tricks authorities play to get a confession.

43 min

22

Nick Nehring

A confession to a lesser crime is still a false confession. When Nick Nehring admits to gunning down a man, claims of self-defense set him up for a shorter sentence. Getting the true story could mean the difference of years in how long this man is taken off the street.

43 min

23

Henry Martin Steiger

Cassandra Robinson hasn't been seen in weeks and her family and friends are getting worried. With a one-year-baby at home, it is uncharacteristic of her to leave for so long. Authorities check in with her partner, entrepreneur Henry Martin Steiger, but he tells them the same thing he's been telling everybody: Cassandra is on vacation. Police then turn to Julian Mesure, Steiger's right hand man, who is confident that Steiger is innocent. Coloured by other witnesses, police are able to put together a different narrative, and confront Mesure a second time... but is it enough to get him to turn on his boss?

43 min

24

Bruce Nixon & Michael Jackson

A husband and wife are buried alive after being robbed. Evidence points to a group that includes Bruce and Michael as being involved. Even in the same investigation, the methods of interrogation utilized to get different suspects to talk can be a stark contrast.

43 min

25

Israel Keyes

When Israel Keyes is apprehended in connection to Samantha Koenig's disappearance, police have no idea that it will lead them to a string of other murders. Despite promising to help authorities solve other missing persons cases and unsolved murders, Keyes is focused on controlling the narrative in the media about how he is portrayed, and the FBI must bite their tongues and suffer through the ramblings of a serial killer if they hope to find out the truth.

43 min

26

Lori Isenberg

Lori calls the police after her husband falls overboard during a boating trip on a lake. What starts as a search and rescue, evolves into something darker, as an investigation reveals there is more to this story. Through multiple interviews the police try to decipher the truth.

43 min